The Law Office of Lance Fletcher, PLLC

New York City DWI Lawyer

Call for a Case Evaluation

212.619.3900
  • Home
  • Practice Areas
  • Contact Us
  • Hiring a DWI Attorney
  • Attorney Profiles
  • Legal Limit in NY
  • Fees
  • FAQ
  • Case Results
  • Case Evaluation
  • Call Today
  • Email Us
  • Our Map
  • Menu
  • Why Hire

    Invaluable Experience from Both Sides of the Courtroom

    Learn More
  • Our Attorneys

    Fighting Tirelessly to Protect Your License & Future

    Get to Know Us
  • FAQs

    24/7 Availability to Address Any Questions You Have

    Get Answers
DWI Blog 2014 December Proving the "D" in DWI
Previous Post  |  Next Post

Proving the "D" in DWI

Posted By Law Offices of Lance Fletcher || 15-Dec-2014

PROVING THE D IN DWI

By Ramy Louis, Esq.

Just because you were found behind the wheel of a car with the keys in the ignition does not necessarily mean that you were driving or "operating" a motor vehicle while intoxicated under New York DWI law. Yes, in order to be found guilty of a DWI in New York, the prosecutor must be able to prove that you were actually "operating" the motor vehicle while you were intoxicated. But while this may sound simple, it is anything but. Over the years, New York courts carved out rule after rule on how the prosecution must prove this element. And these rules may just be the reason your DWI case gets dismissed.

"Operating" a motor vehicle is defined under Vehicle and Traffic Law section 1192 as "proof beyond a reasonable doubt that the defendant had recently driven the vehicle or by such proof that he was seated at the wheel, with the motor running and with a present intention of placing the vehicle in motion." Simply put, you must have been behind the wheel intending to put the car in motion. If you are behind the wheel for any other reason, such as to sleep off your intoxication, warmth, or simply to start the car for someone else, then you may not have been "driving" or "operating" that car under New York DWI laws.

The district attorney's office must prove that you mentally intended to move that vehicle in your intoxicated state. In People v. O'Connor, a defendant was seating behind the wheel of a car with the motor running only to help the owner start the car but defendant had no intention of driving it. All DWI charges were dismissed. 607 N.Y.S.2d 856 (Nassau Co. Dist. Ct. 1994). Another interesting case came up when a defendant got behind the wheel of his car to sleep off his intoxication. While he was asleep, his foot came in contact with the clutch pedal and his car rolled backward into another vehicle. The court in that case ruled that it was impossible to determine intentional operation and DWI charges were dismissed. People v. Edwards, 601 N.Y.S.2d 539 (Oswego City Ct. 1993).

What happens if a police officer orders you to drive the car and you were intoxicated at that time? If you had no intention to drive the car but a police officer orders you to, you may be able to get your DWI charges dismissed. Here are a few examples: In People v. Asche, DWI charges were dismissed in the interest of justice where an intoxicated defendant who had no intention of driving in that condition was ordered to drive a short distance by a police officer. 669 N.Y.S.2d 788 (Nassau Co. Dist. Ct. 1998). Similarly, where a defendant was found asleep behind the wheel of his car while parked in the driveway of a private residence, he was found not be in operating of the car even though police officers instructed her to move the car and she did so. People v. Donovan, 279 N.Y.S.2d 404 (Scarsdale Ct. of Special Sessions 1967).

Proving the "driving" element in a DWI case is not as simple as it may seem. At the Law Offices of Lance Fletcher, we know how to challenge the prosecution's attempt to prove that you were in fact "driving." And we have done so in the past to the benefit of our clients. Contact us for a case evualuation.

Categories: Defenses

Share Post

See What We Can Assist You With

  • Misdemeanor NYC DWI
  • Felony DWI Lawyer
  • Checkpoint DWI
  • Asleep at the Wheel DWI
  • DWI Accident Defense
  • DWI Penalties
  • Manhattan DWI DUI Attorney
  • Brooklyn DWI DUI Attorney
  • Queens DWI,DUI Lawyer
  • DWI Resources
  • Common NY DWI Charges
  • Boating while Intoxicated

Get Your DWI Case Evaluation

Please enter the captcha above:
Contact Our Firm
  • Home
  • Site Map
  • Privacy Policy
  • Contact Us
The Law Office of Lance Fletcher, PLLC

Call Today! (212) 619-3900

The Law Office of Lance Fletcher, PLLC - New York DWI Attorney
52 Duane Street, 7th Floor, New York, NY 10007 View Map
Website: http://www.dwi-attorney-nyc.com/
© 2023 All Rights Reserved.
Internet Marketing Experts The information on this website is for general information purposes only. Nothing on this site should be taken as legal advice for any individual case or situation. This information is not intended to create, and receipt or viewing does not constitute, an attorney-client relationship.