The Law Office of Lance Fletcher, PLLC

New York City DWI Lawyer

Call for a Case Evaluation

212.619.3900
  • Home
  • Practice Areas
  • Contact Us
  • Hiring a DWI Attorney
  • Attorney Profiles
  • Legal Limit in NY
  • Fees
  • FAQ
  • Case Results
  • Case Evaluation
  • Call Today
  • Email Us
  • Our Map
  • Menu
  • Why Hire

    Invaluable Experience from Both Sides of the Courtroom

    Learn More
  • Our Attorneys

    Fighting Tirelessly to Protect Your License & Future

    Get to Know Us
  • FAQs

    24/7 Availability to Address Any Questions You Have

    Get Answers
DWI Blog 2014 November The Intoxication Defense and your DWI case
Previous Post  |  Next Post

The Intoxication Defense and your DWI case

Posted By Law Offices of Lance Fletcher || 21-Nov-2014

The Intoxication Defense and your DWI case

Is intoxication a defense to your DWI case? You might automatically think the answer is "No, of course not" but like most things in the law, the answer is a little more complcated.

Under New York Penal Law Section 15.25, intoxication is not a defense to a criminal charge- but in any prosecution for an offense, evidence of intoxication may be offered by the defense if it is relevant to negate an element of the crime charged. For example, in determining whether a person has the intent and/or knowledge necessary to commit a crime a court may consider whether that person's mind was affected by alcohol to such a degree that he or she was not capable of forming the intent and/or knowledge to commit the crime. When it comes to DWI's, evidence of intoxication comes commonly comes into play in two situations: 1) whether the intoxication itself was voluntary, and 2) whether statements made after an arrest were involuntary as a result of the intoxication.

In the first situation, under New York DWI law, only voluntary intoxication can lead to an arrest for DWI. People v. Koch, 250 A.D. 623 (2d Dept. 1937). Likewise, the New York Court of Appeals in People v. Cruz said that "intoxication is a greater degree of impairment which is reached when the driver has voluntarily consumed alcohol to the extent that he is incapable of employing the physical and mental abilities which he is expected to possess in order to operate a vehicle as a reasonable and prudent driver." 48 N.Y. 2d 419, 428 (1979). Therefore, intoxication must be voluntary in order to be arrested and charged for DWI. It is also important to know that alcoholism and being a chronic alcoholic will not be a defense to driving while intoxicated. People v. Starowicz, 207 A.D. 2d 994 (4th Dept. 1994).

In the second situation, the Second Department has said that "where a defendant's mental state is such that he cannot understand the nature of the Miranda warnings then statements made must be suppressed." People v. Turkenich, 137 A.D. 2d 363 (2d Dept. 1988). This is true even if intoxication is self-induced.

People v. Schompert laid out two main factors in considering whether statements made while drunk will render them involuntary. 19 N.Y. 2d 300 (1967). The first is lack of understanding at the time of confession so that you are unable to appreciate what you are saying. The second is whether what you are saying is accurate. In other words, if you can show that you were so intoxicated to a degree of "mania" that you could not understand the meaning of what you told police then your confession could be ruled as involuntary. Generally, however intoxication alone will not usually render statements involuntary. The intoxication must be to such a high degree so that you cannot understand the meaning of your statements.

Still, intoxication could, under the right circumstances, prevent a damning confession from being used against you in your DWI case which could lead to a dismissal of your case.

If you're facing DWI charges in New York City, contact New York DWI Defense Attorneys at the The Law Offices of Lance Fletcher 212-619-3900 for a case evualuation.

Categories: Defenses

Share Post

See What We Can Assist You With

  • Misdemeanor NYC DWI
  • Felony DWI Lawyer
  • Checkpoint DWI
  • Asleep at the Wheel DWI
  • DWI Accident Defense
  • DWI Penalties
  • Manhattan DWI DUI Attorney
  • Brooklyn DWI DUI Attorney
  • Queens DWI,DUI Lawyer
  • DWI Resources
  • Common NY DWI Charges
  • Boating while Intoxicated

Get Your DWI Case Evaluation

Please enter the captcha above:
Contact Our Firm
  • Home
  • Site Map
  • Privacy Policy
  • Contact Us
The Law Office of Lance Fletcher, PLLC

Call Today! (212) 619-3900

The Law Office of Lance Fletcher, PLLC - New York DWI Attorney
52 Duane Street, 7th Floor, New York, NY 10007 View Map
Website: http://www.dwi-attorney-nyc.com/
© 2023 All Rights Reserved.
Internet Marketing Experts The information on this website is for general information purposes only. Nothing on this site should be taken as legal advice for any individual case or situation. This information is not intended to create, and receipt or viewing does not constitute, an attorney-client relationship.